Back to Home

ERISA Life Insurance Claims

Navigating the Complex Federal Framework for Employer-Sponsored Benefits

Life insurance claims governed by ERISA — the Employee Retirement Income Security Act — require specialized legal knowledge. The Voss Law Firm has deep experience navigating the unique procedural and substantive requirements of ERISA claims.

(260) 239-4029

Free Case Review

Fill out the form below and an attorney will review your case at no cost.

By submitting this form, you agree to be contacted about your case. This does not create an attorney-client relationship.

What Is ERISA?

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) is a federal law that governs most employer-sponsored benefit plans, including group life insurance policies provided through your job. ERISA preempts state law, meaning that claims arising under employer-sponsored plans are subject to a completely different set of rules than individual life insurance policies. ERISA claims are heard in federal court, and the standard of review is often more favorable to the insurance company. This makes it critically important to work with an attorney who understands the unique challenges of ERISA litigation.

The Administrative Appeals Process

Before you can file a lawsuit under ERISA, you are generally required to exhaust the plan's internal administrative appeals process. This means you must file a formal appeal with the insurance company and allow them to review their own decision. The appeal must be filed within strict deadlines — typically 60 to 180 days from the date of denial. The administrative record created during this process is critical because, in many ERISA cases, the court's review is limited to the evidence that was before the plan administrator at the time of the decision. This means that any evidence you fail to submit during the appeal may be excluded from the court's consideration. The Voss Law Firm ensures that every appeal is comprehensive, well-documented, and strategically crafted to build the strongest possible record.

Standards of Review in ERISA Cases

One of the most challenging aspects of ERISA litigation is the standard of review. When the plan gives the insurance company discretionary authority to interpret the plan and determine eligibility for benefits, courts apply an 'abuse of discretion' standard — which is highly deferential to the insurer's decision. However, even under this standard, the insurer's decision must be reasonable and supported by substantial evidence. When the plan does not grant discretionary authority, courts apply a 'de novo' standard, reviewing the claim without deference to the insurer. The Voss Law Firm carefully analyzes the plan language to determine the applicable standard and develops litigation strategies accordingly.

Common ERISA Denial Reasons

Insurance companies deny ERISA life insurance claims for many of the same reasons they deny individual claims — alleged misrepresentation, policy exclusions, and disputes over coverage. However, ERISA adds additional layers of complexity, including questions about whether the employee was eligible for coverage, whether the employer properly enrolled the employee, whether premiums were properly deducted, and whether the plan was properly administered. The Voss Law Firm investigates every aspect of the claim and the plan administration to identify errors and build a compelling case for recovery.

How We Can Help

  • Comprehensive review of the ERISA plan documents and summary plan description
  • Strategic administrative appeals designed to build the strongest possible record
  • Federal court litigation under both abuse of discretion and de novo standards
  • Investigation of plan administration errors and employer compliance failures
  • Recovery of full policy benefits, attorney fees, and pre-judgment interest
  • Nationwide representation in all federal district courts

Free Case Evaluation

If your life insurance claim has been denied, delayed, or underpaid, contact us today. We'll review your case at no cost and no obligation.

(260) 239-4029

Share This Page

Help others who may be facing a similar situation.

Client Testimonial
"Our group life insurance claim was denied under ERISA, and we were told the process was nearly impossible to win. The Voss Law Firm understood the federal regulations inside and out and secured the full policy benefit for our family."

Jennifer T.

Dallas, TX

$750K Recovered

Frequently Asked Questions About ERISA Life Insurance Claims

How do I know if my claim is governed by ERISA?
If your life insurance was provided through your employer as part of a group benefit plan, it is likely governed by ERISA. Individual policies purchased directly from an insurance company are generally not subject to ERISA.
What makes ERISA claims different from other life insurance claims?
ERISA claims are subject to federal law rather than state law, which means different procedural rules, different courts, and often a more restrictive standard of review. You must also exhaust administrative remedies before filing suit, and the evidence you present during the appeal is critical.
Can I recover attorney fees in an ERISA case?
Yes. Under ERISA, the court has discretion to award reasonable attorney fees to the prevailing party. This is an important consideration because it means the insurance company may be required to pay your legal costs if you win.

Don't Wait — Get Help Today

Time limits may apply to your erisa life insurance claims case. The sooner you contact an attorney, the stronger your position will be. Fill out the form for a free, no-obligation case evaluation.

Free consultation. No obligation. Contingency fee — you pay nothing unless we win.

Free Case Review

Fill out the form below and an attorney will review your case at no cost.

By submitting this form, you agree to be contacted about your case. This does not create an attorney-client relationship.